Dan Rather, Still Wrong After All These Years
The movie ‘Truth’ is as bogus as the original attempt to smear George W. Bush’s wartime service.
“Combine every speech about the nobility of the journalistic endeavor in every film glorifying reporters intrepidly searching out truth, and you still won’t come close to grasping the level of treacle—there are other words—bubbling up out of “Truth.” Compared with which, “All the President’s Men” (1976)—about the triumphant adventures of Woodward and Bernstein, with Robert Redford portraying Bob Woodward—was a veritable model of shrinking modesty.
Mr. Redford has come a long way since to his latest, namely the role of CBS’s Dan Rather,former network star and anchor of “60 Minutes II,” and the story of how Mr. Rather was ultimately forced out of the company thanks to the scandal in September 2004 after the airing of a segment called “For the Record.”
The creative minds behind “Truth”—based on a book by the CBS report’s producer, Mary Mapes—have wrapped Mr. Rather and Ms. Mapes in a glow of heroic martyrdom so impenetrable there’s hardly a line not put to its service. When, toward the end, all involved in the report face firing, the film’s fatherly Dan Rather asks a young producer what made him want to go into journalism.
“You,” comes the answer.
The “60 Minutes II” report focused on the alleged special preferences that George W. Bush received as a member of the Texas Air National Guard in the early 1970s, not incidentally suggesting that he did his all to evade duty in Vietnam. The segment aired in the heat of the presidential-election contest between Democratic candidate John Kerryand George W. Bush.
As the exhaustive, and ultimately devastating, independent review of the affair that would become known as “Rathergate” showed, the segment had a way of ignoring facts that subverted its viewpoint. Among the luminaries interviewed was Ben Barnes, former speaker of the Texas House and Kerry supporter. Mr. Barnes said that he had tried, with a well-placed call, to secure a spot for Mr. Bush in the Texas Air National Guard, and that he regretted trying to arrange this preferential treatment because hundreds of people were on the Guard waiting list.
But Mr. Barnes, it turned out, had also said in his interview that he had no idea whether his phone call had any effect—such efforts weren’t always successful. That observation never made it on air. Neither did the fact—which came to light later—that producer Mary Mapes had heard testimony from authoritative sources that flat-out rebutted the claim that there was any list of candidates waiting for a place in the Guard.
All of this was as nothing compared with the now famous bombshell of the fabricated documents that the producers presented as part of their “For the Record” segment—material allegedly from Mr. Bush’s Texas Air National Guard superiors describing his dereliction of duty and official pressure to “sugarcoat” reports about his service.
The documents, which CBS posted online, were almost immediately exposed as forgeries. The final implosion came when Ms. Mapes’s chief source, Bill Burkett, provider of the documents—a retired Texas Air National Guard officer well-known for his bitter rants against the Bush family and for his efforts to discredit George W. Bush’s Guard service—later conceded on-air with Dan Rather in a follow-up report that he had misled the producers about the source of the documents. Documents that he nonetheless still maintained were genuine. Mr. Burkett had told producers that these papers had found their way to him from a range of providers—an anonymous overseas caller, and a mysterious woman, Lucy Ramirez, who had led him to a “dark skinned” stranger who had approached him at the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo.”
Please read on:
http://www.wsj.com/article_email/dan-rather-still-wrong-after-all-these-years-1445295792-lMyQjAxMTA1NDI4MDEyNzAyWj
John Hinderaker’s PowerLine report about this Rathergate evil: http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2015/10/truth-and-other-lies-5.php
Filed under: Corruption, Dishonesty, Journalism, The Press, Truth | 1 Comment »